In the process of evidence-based practice, the evaluation of evidence applicability relied on the subjective judgment of clinicians, while the systematic method of which was still in lack. The complex clinical information of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) enhanced the uncertainty and risk of applying evidence. Based on the analysis of the process of evidence-based practice, this paper introduced the method of TCM evidence applicability evaluation and used the raw data of clinical trials to develop a clinical prediction model to enable the assessment of the evidence applicability on individual patients. The establishment of individual evidence applicability evaluation method could promote the rational application of TCM evidence in the long term.
ObjectiveTo observe the diagnostic sensitivity and specificity of color Doppler flow imaging (CDFI) for persistent hyperplastic primary vitreous (PHPV).
MethodsThe clinical data of 71 children (93 eyes) with congenital cataract which suspected of concurrent PHPV were retrospectively analyzed. The children included 45 males (54 eyes) and 26 females (39 eyes), aged from 1 to 24 months, with an average age of (7.6±4.3) months. All eyes were examined by CDFI, and observe whether there was a pathological strip in the vitreous, the site of the connection between the strip echo and the wall of the eye and the signal of blood flow on the strip echo. Within 1 week after a CDFI examination under general anesthesia, 64 children (79 eyes) underwent lens excision combined with vitrectomy and the other 14 eyes of 7 children underwent mydriatic fundus examination by two experienced eye specialists. Combined with clinical features of PHPV, the diagnosis and differential diagnosis were made according to the clouding of the lens, posterior capsule proliferation, vitreous proliferation and retinal detachment position which were found during operation and fundus examination. Compare and analyze the CDFI examination results and the above diagnosis results, calculate the sensitivity and specificity of CDFI for PHPV.
ResultsIn surgery and mydriatic fundus examination results of 93 eyes, vitreous abnormal in 85 eyes, no significant changes were found in vitreous of the other 8 eyes. In 85 eyes of abnormal vitreous, 68 eyes were diagnosed as PHPV, 16 eyes were diagnosed as familial exudative vitreoretinopathy (FEVR), and 1 eye was diagnosed as treactional retinal detachment. In 85 eyes of abnormal vitreous which were found by surgery and fundus examination, CDFI confirmed 81 eyes and its diagnostic sensitivity was 95.3%; the other 4 eyes were not found vitreous abnormality, and the missed diagnosis rate was 4.7%. Surgery and mydriatic fundus examination found no vitreous abnormal in 8 eyes, but CDFI explored strip low echo connected with the optic disc or posterior lens capsule in vitreous. In the 68 eyes of PHPV which were diagnosed by surgery or fundus examination, 59 eyes had the same diagnosis of CDFI, the sensitivity of CDFI was 86.8%; PHPV was not diagnosed in 25 eyes by surgery or fundus examination, but only 8 eyes were also not diagnosed by CDFI, and the specificity of CDFI was 32.0%. The remaining 17 eyes were diagnosed as FEVR in 16 eyes and traction retinal detachment in 1 eye after surgery or mydriatic fundus examination, but they were all diagnosed as PHPV in CDFI. The misdiagnosis rate of CDFI was 68.0%.
ConclusionFor PHPV, the diagnostic sensitivity and specificity of CDFI are 86.8% and 32.0%, respectively.
