Objective To analyze and evaluate the present status of application of clinical pathway evaluation indexes in China, in order to provide references to establish an evaluation system on clinical pathway. Methods Such databases as CBM (2004-2009), VIP (2004-2009), CNKI (2004-2009) and WanFang Data (2004-2009), and some relevant websites were searched systematically for collecting Chinese literature about domestic clinical pathway evaluation indexes. Results Among the 1 175 articles included, 135 (11%) were published in the core periodicals, 19 (2%) were masterate theses, and 1 021 were other kinds of articles. As to 135 core periodical literature and 19 masterate theses, most of which were graded into the second level of evidence, accounting for 96%. The analysis on the appearance of indexes showed that 87% of inconsistency could be identified between the contents and terms of indexes. Common indexes were summarized as the following four aspects: cost index, clinical index, serving index and quality evaluation index. There were 78% of all the 1 175 articles focusing on the application of nursing and medical education, in which only one masterate thesis used social research methods such as Delphi, focus group, experts scoring (percentile), etc. Conclusion Currently, there are some issues existing in the evaluation indexes of clinical pathway in China, such as low methodological quality of literature, irregularly and randomly using statistical terms, and lack of studies on system construction of clinical pathway evaluation indexes.
ObjectiveTo systematically review the effects of the participation of pharmacists in clinical pathways.MethodsPubMed, The Cochrane Library, EMbase, CBM, CNKI, WanFang Data and VIP databases were electronically searched to collect clinical studies about the participation of pharmacists in clinical pathways from inception to November 2017. Two reviewers independently screened literature, extracted data and assessed the risk of bias of the included studies, then, a descriptive analysis was performed.ResultsA total of 23 studies involving 3 667 participants were included. The key link in which the pharmacists participated in clinical pathways was the implementation of clinical pathways. The participation of pharmacists in clinical pathways could improve the patients’ clinical outcomes, shorten the length of hospital stay, reduce the cost of treatment, improve patient satisfaction and compliance, and promote the rational use of drugs.ConclusionThe participation of pharmacists in clinical pathways could have a positive effect. Due to limited quality and quantity of the included studies, more high quality studies are required to verify the above conclusion.
ObjectiveTo understand the current situation in the treatment of hepatic echinococcosis.
MethodThe literatures about operation treatment, drug treatment, and the clinical pathway of hepatic echinococcosis were reviewed.
ResultsCurrently, with the continuous development of surgical techniques and the application of minimally invasive surgery, the operative treatments of hepatic echinococcosis had made a great progress, it was still the preferred treatment for the disease. Liver transplantation was made as the final choice. The use of aspiration, sclerotherapy or interventional technique brought a hope for patients intolerant to laparotomy. Moreover, chemotherapy drugs, Chinese herbal medicine, and drug combinations also achieved a very good effect in the treatment of hepatic echinococcosis. The clinical pathway provided a good direction for the treatment of hepatic echinococcosis.
ConclusionFor the treatment of hepatic echinococcosis various, we should choice a reasonable treatment according to the specific circumstances of patients, to achieve the best therapeutic effect with minimal trauma.
ObjectivesTo analyze the citation of evidence in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) clinical pathways in China, and to provide suggestions for future development and revision of TCM clinical pathways.MethodsTCM clinical pathways released on the websites of national administration of TCM and China association of Chinese medicine were obtained, with the retrieval time limit to June 2019. Two researchers separately utilized the Excel to extract data and performed a descriptive analysis.ResultsA total of 405 TCM clinical pathways were included, involving internal medicine, surgery, gynecology and pediatrics. Internal medicine accounted for the largest proportion of the TCM clinical pathways (133). All the 405 pathways cited references as evidence, among which the maximum and minimum quantities of cited references were 11 and 1, respectively, and the median was 3. More than 90% of the TCM clinical pathways cited the evidence in the parts of diagnosis and efficacy evaluation. For parts of TCM and western medicine treatment, the proportion of TCM clinical pathways which cited evidence was less than 75%; for parts of rehabilitation and nursing, the proportion of TCM clinical pathways which cited evidence was less than 2%. The types of evidence being cited were standard indicators (683), clinical practice guidelines (488), textbooks (236), consensus opinions, ancient books and clinical surveys. The released time was reported in 89.25% of the cited evidence; the largest time interval was between the release time of the standard indicators (evidence) and that of the TCM pathways. Among the evidence released more than 15 years before the release of the TCM pathways, the proportion of standard indicators was the highest (57.12%).ConclusionsThe published TCM clinical pathways are all developed based on evidence, however, the evidence citation ratio in different parts varies greatly. In some TCM clinical pathways, the cited evidences are not reported normatively, and some evidence are poor in timeliness.
In combination with the national health informatization construction in UK during the past ten years, this article introduced the resource construction of decision making knowledge library like British Electronic Medicine Library Clinical Pathway Database and NHS Evidence, as well as the function and application of clinical decision support system (CDSS) like PRODIGY, medical knowledge map and so on, discussed the development characteristics and construction experiences of British health decision support system (HDSS). And aiming directly at Chinese specific circumstances, this article offered some suggestions on promoting China HDSS development, for instance, dynamically integrating CDSS with patients’ diagnosis and treatment procedure through the electronic medical record system, strengthening the resources construction of knowledge library, establishing localized clinical pathway, and so on.
Due to optimizing medical service resources and improving service efficiency, day surgery has attracted the attention of medical and management experts worldwide. In 2019, day surgery was included as one of the performance assessment indicators of tertiary public hospitals. In recent years, hospital-based day surgery centers have begun to plan and build. Although the basic facilities have been perfectly improved, but how to efficiently and safely operate and manage the centralized day surgery has become the primary problem to clinicians and managers. The purpose of this paper is to introduce how the Day Surgery Center of West China Hospital of Sichuan University uses scientific management tools and establishes a professional multidisciplinary team, so as to carry out efficient operation management and control of medical quality and safety risks of the Day Surgery Center. And then provide practical experience guidance and suggestions with strong feasibility and operability for peers.
ObjectiveTo acquaint the development process and item composition of the appraisal tools and reporting standards of clinical pathways worldwide, in order to improve the development and evaluation of clinical pathways.
MethodsWe searched databases including PubMed, EMbase, Web of Science, CBM, CNKI and WanFang Data for articles about the appraisal tools and reporting standards of clinical pathways from inception to Jan, 2014. Two reviewers independently screened literature according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria, extracted data, and compared the difference in development process and item composition among included appraisal tools and reporting standards of clinical pathways.
ResultsA total of 7 appraisal tools and reporting standards were included. Among them, 3 were from UK, 1 from China, 1 from Australia, 1 from Belgium, and 1 from Saudi Arabia. All included appraisal tools contained 4 to 15 domains and 14 to 99 items. Based on the comparison of different domains and items of included appraisal tools, "Clinical Pathway Management Guidelines" published by the National Health and Family Planning Commission of the People's Republic of China and the research of Vannhaecht, we identified 17 key elements of clinical pathway as follows:organizational commitment, pathway project management, format of doc, content of pathway, multidisciplinary involvement, variance management, EBM/guidelines, maintenance of pathway, accountability, patient involvement, development of pathway, additional support systems & documents, operational arrangement, implementation, outcome management, safety and organization of the care process.
ConclusionCurrently, the appraisal tools and reporting standards of clinical pathways are rudimentary, so we desperately needs to establish mature appraisal tool and reporting standard of clinical pathways to guide the development and implementation of clinical pathway, so as to improve their application effects in clinical practice and medical quality.
Objective To evaluate the feasibility of the clinical pathway based on the medical data information integration system to guide the treatment of palmar hyperhidrosis (PHH).
Methods We retrospectively analyzed the clinical data of 106 PHH patients in the Fourth Affiliated Hospital of Harbin Medical University from March 2012 through June 2015. The patients were divided into two groups including a day surgery group (52 patients) and a traditional group (54 patients). The patients in the day surgery group underwent day surgery guided by clinical pathway of PHH based on medical data information integration system. The patients in the traditional group stayed in hospital for 2-3 days. The pre-surgical situation, post-surgical effect of patients and cost of hospitalization were compared between the two groups.
Results Only one patient of PPH suffered from insufficient relief of symptoms. The other patients’ symptom of PPH disappeared. No serious complication occurred. The postoperative visual analogue scale (VAS) pain score of patients was lower than 2 points. The hospitalization expense of the day surgery group was significantly lower than that of the traditional operation group. The average follow-up time was 2.5 months (0.5 to 4 months). The symptoms of the whole group had no recurrence. All of the patients were not found with compensatory hyperhidrosis.
Conclusion Day-surgery clinical pathway of PHH based on medical data information integration system is safe and feasible. Day-surgery clinical pathway of PPH can accelerate the recovery of patients and save the cost of hospitalization.
ObjectiveTo explore the effect of clinical pathway in peri-operative nursing management of patients with esophageal carcinoma.
MethodsA total of 120 patients with esophageal cancer who underwent the operation between January 2010 and April 2012 were divided into control group and trial group. the patients in control group was given conventional esophageal carcinoma peri-operative management; while the ones in the trial group received clinical pathway standardized management. The hospitalization days, costs of hospitalization, complications, satisfaction of the patients and families were compared between the two groups.
ResultsThe length of hospitalization days and costs in the trial group were lower than those in the control group (P<0.01); the patients and families satisfaction in the trial group was superior to the control group (P<0.05); the difference in complications occurrence between the two groups was not significant (P>0.05).
ConclusionThe clinical pathway of peri-operative nursing management for patients with esophageal cancer could effectively decrease the costs, improve satisfaction of the patients and families, and ensure the quality of care and improve the nursing efficiency.
Objective To explore a scientific disease cost accounting. Method Disease cost accounting = disease cost accounting of clinic pathway + disease basis cost accounting. Conclusions It is the tendency with the medical reform for the social security department to pay by disease for the hospitals, as a result, both social security department and hospitals have to resort to the scientific way in terms of cost accounting of disease. And it is practical and effective by means of cost accounting for clinic pathway.
