Objective To explore the methods of evidence-based individualized treatment for a patient with oral pemphigus. Methods According to chnical problems, we searched The Coehrane Library （Issue 1,2005 ） , MEDLINE （1966 -Jan. 2005 ）, SUMSEAR.CH （Jan. 2005 ）, TRIPDATABASE （1997 - 2005 ）, CMCC （1994 - 2004 ）and handsearched four Chinease journals （starting pubhcation -2004）. Results No Systematic review was found. Six randomised controlled trials, two reviews of high quality and one guidehne were identified. We found that corticosteroid was the firsthne medicine in the treatment of pemphigus. However, corticosteroid at higher dose did not work more effectively than that at lower dose. Corticosteroid at middle-dose was preferred in treating oral pemphigus. Additionally, corticosteroid combined with immunosuppressants led to lower mortality. Among them, cyclophosphamide and azathioprine were recommended, and methopterin should be avoided. Plasma exchange in combination with corticosteroid at lowor middle-dose should not be recommended in conventional therapy. Chinese traditional treatment combined with Western medicine might work. A treatment with prednisone at the dose of 60 mg/d and in combination with azathioprine 100mg/d was made based on the evaluation of the data available and was proved optimal by 6 months following-up. Conclusions The therapeutic effect of pemphigus has been improved by evidence-based treatment.
Objective Evidence-based medicine was used to make an individualized treatment plan for newly diagnosed prostatic hyperplasia in an elderly patient. Methods After clinical problems were discovered, evidence was collected from CBM, CNKI, The Cochrane Library, PubMed, EMBASE, ScienceDirect, Springer, and ProQuest databases according to our predefined search strategy. The search was done through 2008. The internal and external validity of the evidence was assessed. The evidence, combined with the patient value, was applied to the patient. Results A total of 39 systematic reviews involving 137 randomized controlled trials were identified. A rational treatment plan was made upon a critical evaluation of the data. After one year follow-up, the treatment protocol was proven correct. Conclusion The treatment efficacy in newly diagnosed prostatic hyperplasia in the elderly has been improved by determining an individualized treatment protocol according to evidence-based methods.
Objective To make an individualized therapeutic regimen for a patient with stage III relapsed ovarian cancer guided by evidence-based medicine.Methods According to the clinical problems this patient showed and the PICO (patient, intervention, comparison and outcome) principle, the best clinical evidence associated with relapsed ovarian cancer was retrieved and evaluated. Results The current evidence showed that the relapsed ovarian cancer with platinum resistance tended to be treated by pharmacotherapy. Consequently, on the basis of combining the recommended guidelines, randomized controlled trials (RCTs), systematic reviews or meta-analyses on RCTs, clinical experience from doctors and willingness of patient, the regimen of Irinotecan plus Pegylated Liposomal Doxorubicin for interventional chemotherapy was recommended for this patient. After three courses of the treatment, the disease got some relieved; the medical team would like to keep conducting the same regimen for another six to eight courses, and the follow-up visit was undergoing. Conclusion For patients with relapsed ovarian cancer with platinum resistance, an individualized therapeutic regimen under the guidance of evidence-based methods can not only improve the therapeutic efficacy but also guide both doctors and patients to take the indeterminate risk of medicine.
Objective To make an evidence-based treatment plan for a smoker with periimplantitis. Methods Based on the clinical problems raised from the case, we searched The Cochrane Library (Issue 2, 2009), ACP Journal Club (1991 to July 2009), MEDLINE (1950 to July 2009), EMbase (1980 to July 2009) and Chinese Journal Fulltext Database (1994 to July 2009) for guidelines, systematic reviews, meta-analyses and randomized controlled trials (RCTs). The quality of the included studies was assessed. Results A total of 4 systematic reviews, 8 RCTs were included. The following methods were supported by Level A evidence: (1) Scaling combined with local antibiotics; (2) Guided bone regeneration; (3) Non-surgical debridement with titanium hand-instruments or with an ultrasonic device. Based on the available evidence, we proposed a three-stage therapy plan for the patient: In the first stage, full mouth ultrasonic scaling was performed. The peri-implant pocket was debrided with plastic curettes, and then minocycline gel was applied once a week for four times. The patient was persuaded to maintain oral hygiene and quit smoking. In the second stage, four weeks later, open flap debridement and guided bone regeneration were conducted. In the third stage, long-term care of oral hygiene and dental implants were performed. After 6 months of follow-up, the peri-implant tissues were healthy with no evidence of inflammation, bleeding or suppuration. Conclusion Based on the approach of evidence-based medicine, we accomplished the treatment of the case with reliable outcomes.
Objective Making an individualized pharmacological treatment plan for a patient of acute respiratory distress syndrome after operation. Methods First, six clinical problems were put forward after assessing the patient’ s health state. Then we searched OVID versions of the ACP Journal Club (1991~2009), CENTRAL (1st Quarter 2009), CDSR (1st Quarter 2009), and MEDLINE (1991~2009) databases. Systematic reviews, meta-analyses, and randomized clinical trials about treatment of acute respiratory distress syndrome were included. The pharmacological treatment plan was made accordingly.Results After evaluation, 13 studies were eligible. The evidence indicated that the restrictive strategy of fluid management, corrected hypoproteinaemia, diuresis, and low-dose corticosteroids given in the early phase could improve oxygenation and prognosis; inhaled nitric oxide, exogenous surfactant supplement, other pharmacological drugs were associated with limited improvement in oxygenation in patients with ARDS but confer no mortality benefit and may cause harm, so we did not recommend their routine use in ARDS patients. The individual treatment plan was made based on the evidence found. After 8 days of treatment, the patient was out the ICU. He recovered and was discharged after 1 month. Conclusions The individual treatment plan, which was made based on high quality evidence and patient’s condition, improved treatment efficacy, shortened the stay in ICU, reduced mortality, and decreased adverse reactions.
Objective To make an evidence-based remedy for a patient with cerebral veins and sinuses thrombosis (CVST), who had an unsatisfactory response to routine treatment. Methods We searched the Cochrane Library (Issue 3, 2005), PubMed (1966 to 2005), CNKI (1979 to 2005) and VIP (1989 to 2005) to identify systematic reviews (SRs), randomized controlled trials (RCTs), controlled clinical trials (CCTs) and prospective cohort studies about efficacy and safety of anticoagulants and thrombolysis therapy for CVST. Results We found 1 systematic review, 3 RCTs and 8 prospective cohort studies about anticoagulation therapy and 2 SRs and 1 CCT about thrombolysis therapy. Routine anticoagulation and thrombolysis for patients with CVST are not recommended due to insufficient evidence. Anticoagulation appeared to be safer and could prevent pulmonary embolism. According to the current evidence, the patient’s status and will, anticoagulants were given. His symptoms relieved and he had no subsequent hemorrhages or pulmonary embolism. Conclusion Patients with CVST should receive anticoagulation treatment with monitoring of de novo hemorrhages and the index of hemostasis and coagulation. Large-sample RCTs comparing the effect and safety of anticoagulant with placebo and RCTs comparing the effect and safety of anticoagulation therapy with that of endovascular thrombolysis therapy in high-risk patients are needed.
Objective To report an evidence-based treatment of Mycophenolate Mofetil for idiopathic membranous nephropathy (IMN) with nephrotic syndrome (NS). Methods We searched The Cochrane Library (Issue 3, 2005), MEDLINE (1978 to 2006) and CNKI (1978 to 2006), and critically appraised the available evidence. Results The available Level C (low quality) evidence showed that Mycophenolate Mofetil was effective for the remission of proteinuria, and effective in patients who were resistant to steroid or cytotoxic agents. However, there was no evidence on its long-term effect on renal survival. Given the current evidence, together with our clinical experience and the patient’s preference, Mycophenolate Mofetil and glucocorticoid were administered to the patient. After 3 months of treatment, proteinuria was relieved. The patient is still can followed up. Conclusions We only find Level C evidence to support the short-term efficacy of Mycophenolate Mofetil on the remission of proteinuria. Further studies on its long-term effects on renal survival, and a health economics evaluation are needed.
Objective To search evidence in the treatment of Philadelphia chromosome （Ph）-positive acute lymphocytic leukemia （ALL） for guiding chnical practice. Methods We searched MEDLINE （February, 1970～July, 2005 ） and SUMSEAILCH （till July, 2005 ）to identify systematic reviews（SIL）, randomized controlled trials（RCTs） and controlled clinical trials （CCTs） in the treatment of Ph-positive ALL. Results One RCT and 8 CCTs were identified. The results showed that Ph-positive ALL had a very poor prognosis . Chemotherapy and bone marrow transplantation （BMT） were the two main ways to treat the disease. Outcome of conventional chemotherapy treatment for adults with the disease was poor. Outcome of treatment with hyper-CVAD and imatinib mesylate was better and BMT was the only way which could potentially cure the disease. Conclusions Treatment of Ph-positive ALL with hyper-CVAD and imatinib mesylate may induce higher remission rate and disease free survival rate. BMT is the best way to cure the disease.
Objective To discuss the diagnosis, treatment, and follow-up visit mode of thyroid carcinoma showing thymus-like elements (CASTLE). Mothods For a systematic review of a case with CASTLE, the domestic and overseas literature was searched to analyze final diagnosis, treatment and follow-up visit indexes of that case. Results For CASTLE, the pathology combined with immunohistochemistry was the only method for final diagnosis, the operation was the main treatment, and the ultrasound as well as the computed tomography (CT) could be the follow-up visiting indexes. Conclusion CASTLE is a special kind of thyroid carcinoma, which is different from differentiated thyroid carcinoma in diagnosis, treatment and follow-up visit.
