ObjectivesTo explore the statistical performance of different methods for meta-analysis of single rates with zero events so as to provide evidence for selecting meta-analysis methods in evidence-based research.MethodsThrough Monte-Carlo simulations, we evaluated the performance of various transformation and correction methods for meta-analysis of single rates with zero events, considering the point estimate bias, confidence interval coverage and width.ResultsWhen the overall event rate was above 30%, all methods showed good statistical performance. As the event rate dropped, log, logit, and arcsine transformations could still maintain good performance. However, when the event rate was less than 5%, only Freeman-Tukey transformation showed excellent performance.ConclusionsThe meta-analysis of single rate based on Freeman-Tukey transformation is robust, and should be recommended as the preferable choice of meta-analysis of single rate with zero events.
